Updated: Jun 24, 2022
Whether you are a student, faculty member, or parent, the future of higher education is uncertain. The entire college experience has been condensed into a series of web conferences and online assignments. It is convenient to be able to join a live classroom with a few clicks, or watch recorded sessions later, but what is the true cost of Zoom University compared to four years on a leafy campus?
For many people around the world, college is already too expensive. Every semester students who were successful in their studies are forced to drop out because of cost. The price of college has skyrocketed. For institutions to think they can replicate the university experience with Zoom, then charge the same high prices, is going to be tough.
The problem is that there are no real alternatives to a good college education. Those of us who have had the privilege can appreciate the intrinsic value. It's not just those classes, but those spontaneous interactions, hangouts, friendships, relationships, rewards, challenges, anything and everything in between that makes the college experience so special. How much of that experience can be replicated online, without students being physically close to each other all the time?
The short answer is a lot, but it can’t be done by just cobbling together a bunch of programs that weren’t even designed for higher education in the first place. Most of us have used social media forums like Facebook and LinkedIn, newsfeeds like Twitter or Gab, and online hangouts to make our digital lives a proxy for our physical world. But for education there needs to be more blending of modern technology with proven pedagogical practices. If institutions want to charge the same amount of money for remote learning that they do for in-person, they better add a ton of value to the former offering.
In a short period of time the pandemic left many administrations struggling to figure out a system for online learning, turning it from “nice to have” to “totally essential.” This was not an ideal way to design curriculum and it was not an easy transition for students and instructors. Zoom, Slack, and Microsoft Teams have been lifesavers, but they are not the boats you would board for a long journey. Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn are tools designed for the consumer internet, without the deeper considerations for engaging online learning environments.
In a recent article, Jeffery R. Young observed, “While many of these hastily-created online experiences are improvisational rather than well-engineered learning programs, the increased use and awareness of the kinds of digital educational tools available could underlie a new culture of more evidence-based teaching.” That means the murky phenomenon of delivering a stellar education could be distilled into more of an exact science when carried out online. An instructor cannot see if a student is actually reading the materials or surfing the net, but software certainly can. If Google or Facebook can show you targeted advertisements, why not use similar targeting technology to showcase verified educational content to our learners? Online platforms provide metrics that can be used to establish KPIs. Teachers and administrators can gather the kinds of rich participation and progression data that is impossible to measure in a classroom.
There is now speculation that top tier universities are going to establish or expand partnerships with tech companies to create these massive programs. Scott Galloway thinks this will have a permanent impact on the university landscape. In a recent New York Magazine interview, he predicts “Hundreds, if not thousands, of brick-and-mortar universities will go out of business and those that remain will have student bodies composed primarily of the children of the one percent.”
Elite universities will not gain a monopoly on higher education—they don’t want one. They are elite because they are selective, and offer unique learning experiences. Some of that experience can be scaled online, but there is an obvious limit if they don’t want to compromise quality. MIT already makes almost all of its lecture videos freely available through its MIT OpenCourseware. MIT obviously recognizes that the value of a campus-based education is not only in the content, syllabus, or assignments, but the environment.
The real value of online program